M.S. and Others v. Romania
Application no. 27737/22 · Articles 3 and 8Judgment on HUDOC ↗- What happened
- A mother reported to the police and to child protection services that the father was abusing their two children, including behaviour of a sexual nature towards their daughter. The criminal investigation lasted almost five years and was closed without charges. The girl was examined by psychiatrists in the presence of the father she accused, and the five-year-old boy was also interviewed in his presence.
- What the Court decided
- The investigation was neither prompt nor effective and lacked the diligence required in cases involving child victims. The Court criticised interviewing the children in front of the alleged abuser and raised serious concerns about the training of the professionals involved. The State must pay the two children 15,000 and 10,000 euros.
- Why it matters
- A child who reports abuse must be heard without delay, by trained professionals, and never be made to face the person they accuse.
